+1 for Rotwang to join contrib even thouh i've said it a number of times in irc. Regards, Danny Rawlins <Romster>
+1 for Rotwang to join contrib even thouh i've said it a number of times in irc. I think you should only vote on crux-contrib, and send a mail to this
Hi Danny, On Mon, May 12, 2008 at 11:05:28 +1000, Danny Rawlins wrote: list once a consensus has been reached among the contrib developers. crux-devel should have no influence on the application process of 'contrib' IMO, nor have to count votes and take the final decision. Keep in mind that this request for a new contrib account should also include the user name the user wants for git. HTH, Johannes -- Johannes Winkelmann mailto:jw@smts.ch Zurich, Switzerland http://jw.smts.ch
Johannes Winkelmann [2008-05-12 09:41]:
Hi Danny,
+1 for Rotwang to join contrib even thouh i've said it a number of times in irc. I think you should only vote on crux-contrib, and send a mail to this
On Mon, May 12, 2008 at 11:05:28 +1000, Danny Rawlins wrote: list once a consensus has been reached among the contrib developers. crux-devel should have no influence on the application process of 'contrib' IMO, nor have to count votes and take the final decision.
Yes, that's what I mentioned in #crux a couple of times, but... Anyway, I created Bartłomiej's account last night :) Regards, Tilman -- A: Because it messes up the order in which people normally read text. Q: Why is top-posting such a bad thing? A: Top-posting. Q: What is the most annoying thing on usenet and in e-mail?
Johannes Winkelmann wrote:
Hi Danny,
On Mon, May 12, 2008 at 11:05:28 +1000, Danny Rawlins wrote:
+1 for Rotwang to join contrib even thouh i've said it a number of times in irc.
I think you should only vote on crux-contrib, and send a mail to this list once a consensus has been reached among the contrib developers. crux-devel should have no influence on the application process of 'contrib' IMO, nor have to count votes and take the final decision.
Keep in mind that this request for a new contrib account should also include the user name the user wants for git.
HTH, Johannes
I posted to crux-devel because of tilman. [04:44:04] <Rotwang> so, what im supposed to do next ;] two days ago i didnt get straight answer, [04:59:29] <tilman> hassle the contrib people to make up their mind [05:00:29] <Rotwang> i thought they did ;] [05:00:36] <Rotwang> romster and mike_k [05:00:41] <Rotwang> but ok [05:00:44] <tilman> dunno, they didn't contact crux-devel [...] [05:02:10] <Rotwang> so some contrib member should contact crux-devel [...] [05:02:32] <Rotwang> http://crux.nu/Main/ContribRules isnt too specific [05:02:39] <Rotwang> about whole process ;] [05:02:42] <sepen> <Rotwang> romster and mike_k [05:02:44] <sepen> me too [...] [05:28:37] <tilman> meh [05:28:48] <tilman> > Awaiting second contrib maintainer approval/disapproval [05:28:57] <tilman> does rotwang have two advocates now? [...] [05:30:03] <sepen> tilman, more than two [05:30:15] <mike_k> I am not sure who is the first [05:32:51] <Rotwang> romster [05:33:33] <Rotwang> http://lists.crux.nu/pipermail/crux-contrib/2008-April/000825.html [05:34:47] <mike_k> ah [05:41:08] <tilman> Rotwang: i'll set you up with an account later After reading all that I emailed to crux-devel as tilman said too... Regards, Danny Rawlins <Romster> * *
Danny Rawlins [2008-05-12 18:03]:
Johannes Winkelmann wrote:
Hi Danny,
On Mon, May 12, 2008 at 11:05:28 +1000, Danny Rawlins wrote:
+1 for Rotwang to join contrib even thouh i've said it a number of times in irc.
I think you should only vote on crux-contrib, and send a mail to this list once a consensus has been reached among the contrib developers. crux-devel should have no influence on the application process of 'contrib' IMO, nor have to count votes and take the final decision.
Keep in mind that this request for a new contrib account should also include the user name the user wants for git.
HTH, Johannes
I posted to crux-devel because of tilman. [...]
Sorry, I guess what I said was misleading. What I meant is: 1.) contrib people reach a consensus 2.) one contrib person writes to crux-devel saying that they did reach a consensus, what the solution is etc. The vote casting should be done in contrib space only ;) Regards, Tilman -- A: Because it messes up the order in which people normally read text. Q: Why is top-posting such a bad thing? A: Top-posting. Q: What is the most annoying thing on usenet and in e-mail?
Tilman Sauerbeck wrote:
Danny Rawlins [2008-05-12 18:03]:
Johannes Winkelmann wrote:
Hi Danny,
On Mon, May 12, 2008 at 11:05:28 +1000, Danny Rawlins wrote:
+1 for Rotwang to join contrib even thouh i've said it a number of times in irc.
I think you should only vote on crux-contrib, and send a mail to this list once a consensus has been reached among the contrib developers. crux-devel should have no influence on the application process of 'contrib' IMO, nor have to count votes and take the final decision.
Keep in mind that this request for a new contrib account should also include the user name the user wants for git.
HTH, Johannes
I posted to crux-devel because of tilman. [...]
Sorry, I guess what I said was misleading. What I meant is: 1.) contrib people reach a consensus 2.) one contrib person writes to crux-devel saying that they did reach a consensus, what the solution is etc. The vote casting should be done in contrib space only ;)
Regards, Tilman
Ah sorry for the posting to crux-devel then i didn't get what you ment, now that clears that up, I also think Rotwang should have his mxq on flyspray changed to 'rotwang' as is his contrib account name to keep things consistent. Regards, Danny Rawlins <Romster>
Danny Rawlins [2008-05-12 18:13]:
Tilman Sauerbeck wrote:
Danny Rawlins [2008-05-12 18:03]:
Johannes Winkelmann wrote:
Hi Danny,
On Mon, May 12, 2008 at 11:05:28 +1000, Danny Rawlins wrote:
+1 for Rotwang to join contrib even thouh i've said it a number of times in irc.
I think you should only vote on crux-contrib, and send a mail to this list once a consensus has been reached among the contrib developers. crux-devel should have no influence on the application process of 'contrib' IMO, nor have to count votes and take the final decision.
Keep in mind that this request for a new contrib account should also include the user name the user wants for git.
HTH, Johannes
I posted to crux-devel because of tilman. [...]
Sorry, I guess what I said was misleading. What I meant is: 1.) contrib people reach a consensus 2.) one contrib person writes to crux-devel saying that they did reach a consensus, what the solution is etc. The vote casting should be done in contrib space only ;)
Regards, Tilman
Ah sorry for the posting to crux-devel then i didn't get what you ment, now that clears that up, I also think Rotwang should have his mxq on flyspray changed to 'rotwang' as is his contrib account name to keep things consistent.
I think FlySpray displays the real name attached to an account everywhere it matters... you hardly get to see the login name. Regards, Tilman -- A: Because it messes up the order in which people normally read text. Q: Why is top-posting such a bad thing? A: Top-posting. Q: What is the most annoying thing on usenet and in e-mail?
participants (4)
-
Danny Rawlins -
Johannes Winkelmann -
Jose V Beneyto -
Tilman Sauerbeck